Essays On Partial Birth Abortion

Partial Birth Abortion Essay

Claim of Fact Argument

The claim of fact presented in this argument is that babies/fetuses feel intense pain during the partial-birth abortion procedure. This is one of the main reasons that partial-birth abortions should be banned. The support for this claim is that the physicians and specialist in this area say so. The warrant for this support is that the physicians and specialist in this area are very prominent and credible for their work in this area.

The argument of whether partial-birth abortion should be legal has been going on since the Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act was made a bill. The Partial Birth Abortion Ban Act is a bill that would ban partial-birth abortions at any stage in pregnancy unless the baby/fetus was going to endanger the mother's life. A partial birth abortion is an abortion in which the person performing the abortion partially delivers a living fetus/baby before killing the fetus and completing the delivery.

A partial-birth baby is one that has been in the womb for 4-6 months. At one time these abortions were thought to be rare. However, a PBS program that aired in January 1997 proved otherwise. Dr. James McMahon had developed a method of abortion in the 7th month that he performed some 2,000 times. Out of these 2,000 abortions, only 9% were proved for health reason. The most common reason for the remaining 91% was depression. This is not a justifiable reason for murder, innocent babies are being killed for personal reasons. The Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act would put an end to such activity.

Recently the Physicians' Ad Hoc Coalition for Truth (PHACT- a group of over 500 physician specialists) met to discuss partial-birth abortions. They discovered that partial-birth abortions are not medically necessary to protect a mother's health or future fertility. Besides that they stated that the procedure is a major threat to both the mother and her fetus. This proves that this procedure is not needed and therefore should be outlawed.

Witnesses to this procedure who once supported partial-birth abortions are now against them. In September 1993, Brenda Pratt Shaper, a thirteen-year, nurse was assigned to a job at an abortion clinic. At the time she considered herself pro-choice thus did not think that the task was going to be a problem. She was asked to assist a doctor during a partial-birth abortion. She...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

Abortion Essay

924 words - 4 pages                Partial-Birth Abortion Act      During the Clinton administration the Partial-Birth Abortion Act, a bill that would make it illegal in all of the United States for a partial-birth abortion to be performed, caused major debate throughout the House of Representatives and the Senate; recently different versions of the bill had been...

The Abortion Debate: It Will Never End

2412 words - 10 pages Abortion has become an issue Americans feel strongly about, and it has created enormous debates within the United States. It has been around for years, and is certainly not a new option for women who find themselves in an unwanted pregnancy. Even though terminations have become safer for women, there are still strong arguments against abortion. Whether one is for or against abortion depends on a combination of beliefs, as well as pressures from...

Societal Views on Abortion

625 words - 3 pages When asked about abortion most people try not to even think about the subject. “Abortion is the termination of a pregnancy after, accompanied by, resulting in, or closely followed by the death of the embryo or fetus.” (Merrian-Webster) Since abortion was legalized in 1973 there have been over 35 million abortions performed. Approximately 1 in every 6 women has had an abortion, giving a total of about 4,000 abortions each day in the United States...

Should Women Have the Right to Abortion?

1262 words - 5 pages One morning in June 8, 1964 a woman was found “naked, kneeling, collapsed upon the floor, with a bloody towel between her legs” by a maid in a motel room in Connecticut. Gerri Santoro is one of the many American women that died from an induced illegal abortion in the United States prior to Roe v. Wade. Unfortunately since then anti-abortion activists have tried to revoke these rights and have successfully pass excessive regulations and...

Exploring the Abortion Issue

3867 words - 15 pages Exploring the Abortion Issue When it comes to abortion one can not state that there is simply a conflict between a woman’s right to privacy/autonomy of her body (i.e. the right to choose) and the right to life (particularly the right of the fetus to be born). It is also not adequate to claim that the alternating theories of when life is created is at the core of the conflict over abortion, because the definition of the creation of life does...

Undercover Murder

1733 words - 7 pages According to Mother Teresa, “Many people are very, very concerned with the children in India, with the children in Africa where quite a number die, maybe of malnutrition, of hunger and so on, but millions are dying deliberately by the will of the mother. And this is what the greatest destroyer of peace is today. Because if a mother can kill her own child - what is left for me to kill you and you kill me -- there is nothing between” (“Abortion...

The Real Tragedy of Abortion

1632 words - 7 pages Abortion is a very popular trend around the world, it has been going on since the beginning of time. Many people would agree that abortion is very bad and unethical. Nearly 700,000 babies have been killed in the United States since 1973, with the right lies and planning all of those babies could have been saved. Abortion is a negative of society as shown by the torturing of a life, self harm, and the message it sends to others. There is no...

Pro-Life or Pro-Choice?

939 words - 4 pages Abortion has become a major issue in the United States. Various groups define abortion terms differently. Most pro-life and conservation Christians follow more moral issues and meanings. Supporters who are pro-choice follow more medical issues. In my opinion, I do not think that it should be left up to the government to decide whether a woman can have one or not. I...

Women's rights in the US

2364 words - 9 pages Statement of integrity:I hereby declare that I am familiar with the rules of Zuyd University AS concerning plagiarism and I am aware of the possible consequences should my thesis be found not to be my own work or in violation of these rules. I hereby state that I used proper referencing - both in the body and in my works cited - if I found my information elsewhere and that no information, nor ideas which are not my own were used in this...


1549 words - 6 pages Over the last thirty years, abortion policies have been the most controversial of all political and legal issues in the United States. Each state has its own laws and regulations concerning abortion. These laws mainly refer to the conditions in which abortion is legal, the requirements for minors who make the decision of having an abortion, and the government's funding for people having an abortion. The United States government has played a...


587 words - 2 pages ABORTION Abortion is the removal of the product of conception before the embryo or fetus is viable. "Any interruption of human pregnancy subsequent to the 28th week is known as abortion"(The Columbia Encyclopedia, Edition 5, 1993 p157). There are many types of abortion procedures, some can be done as late as the sixth month of pregnancy. Here are seven of the most common types, "Morning after pill, RU486(mifepristone), Uterine or...

This paper reflects the research and thoughts of a student at the time the paper was written for a course at Bryn Mawr College. Like other materials on Serendip, it is not intended to be "authoritative" but rather to help others further develop their own explorations. Web links were active as of the time the paper was posted but are not updated.

Contribute Thoughts | Search Serendip for Other Papers | Serendip Home Page

Biology 103
2003 First Paper
On Serendip

Partial Birth Abortion

Katherine Ottati

In the continuing debates on the legality and morality of abortion, "partial birth" abortions have become a hot topic. What exactly is a partial birth abortion? Nebraska state legislation defines it as "an abortion procedure in which the person performing the abortion partially delivers a living unborn child before killing the unborn child and completing delivery" (1). While this definition may be fine for legal purposes, it still does not address the actual procedures; we still do not know what an actual partial birth abortion procedure entails.

The most common procedure is called Intact Dilation and Evacuation, or D&E. D&E involves dismembering the fetus inside the uterine cavity and then pulling it out through the already dilated cervix (1) . Another less common, but more controversial method is the dilation and extraction method, or D&X. This procedure requires a woman to take medication several days in advance to dilate the cervix. Once the cervix has dilated, she returns to complete the procedure. When she returns, the physician turns the fetus around in the uterus so that it is positioned feet first, and then delivers the fetus until only the head remains inside the mother's body. At this point, the physician punctures the base if the skull and suctions out the contents of the fetus' head, causing the skull to collapse. The dead fetus is then removed from the woman's body (2). In each case the head (or more) is left inside the woman's body because in order for a birth to have occurred under common law the head of the fetus must leave the mother's body. Under the current interpretation of the United States Constitution, a person must be born in order to be protected by the government, so by leaving the head in the mother's body the procedure is considered to be legally viable (1).

Proponents of a ban on partial birth abortions cite what they see as the extreme cruelty of the procedures as violating the constitutional rights of the fetus. They believe that birth should be defined as occurring as soon as any part of the fetus' torso above the navel is visible, or when any of the fetus' body has left the mother (1). Many argue that since the fetus in undoubtedly alive during the procedure, the issue of whether or not an actual birth has occurred should be of little consequence (3). Since partial birth abortions are performed late-term, many of the fetuses could in fact be self-sustaining outside of the mother's body.

Those who oppose the ban argue that it jeopardizes the health and safety of the mother. Since all partial birth abortion bans presented in Congress and state legislatures have been vague as to which procedures they prohibit, the overall threat to women's health is too great and would place an "undue burden" on the women in question (1). Late term abortion procedures that are not partial birth involve dismembering the fetus inside the uterus without cervical dilation, which can leave behind fetal tissue, or require the head to come out of the mother's body uncollapsed, which can result in a live birth (1). In either of these procedures, there is a higher risk of puncturing the uterus or damaging the cervix than there is with partial birth methods (2). Banning partial birth abortions would leave these procedures as the only option for late term abortion. Additionally, none of the partial birth bans have included clauses allowing such procedures if they are necessary to the mother's health and well-being. This means that if a woman had to have a late term abortion to save her own life, she would be forced to choose a riskier procedure. Since few women choose to terminate after seven to eight months of pregnancy for non-health related reasoning, it follows that most women seeking a late term abortion would be put in a difficult position. This is what the anti-ban groups mean when they refer to an undue burden on the mother's health (4).

When I began my investigation, I was sure of my position on abortion rights, and convinced that little could change my mind, regardless of what the procedures actually involved. However, when reading the case made by the pro-ban side of the argument, I could not help but agree with certain things they said. Does birth really define life? I'm not so sure that I agree that it does. Does this mean that I completely disapprove of partial birth abortion? No � I still feel that a woman should be able to choose the safest method available, and in the case of late term abortions, partial birth procedures have obvious benefits. The information I gathered has, however, caused me to question my unconditional support of the procedures � should elective abortions really be allowed if the procedures are as, well, unpleasant as partial birth methods are? What I once thought were clear cut lines between the legal, the biological and the sentimental aspects of the issue have blurred.


1)Partial Birth Abortion Laws , A listing of federal and state laws and proposed legislation concerning partial birth abortions.

2) Abortion, Partial Birth , Basic descriptions of the process from a relatively unbiased viewpoint.

3) Partial Birth Abortion" Is It Really Happening? , Pro-ban viewpoint with illustrations of D&X procedure.

4)Partial Birth Abortions: Myths and Facts , Cited facts/myths appear in a pop up window accessible through the page. Anti-ban viewpoint.

| Biology 103 | Course Forum Area | Biology | Serendip Home |

Send us your comments at Serendip
© by Serendip 1994- - Last Modified: Saturday, 18-Nov-2017 15:50:28 EST

0 thoughts on “Essays On Partial Birth Abortion

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *